It's exactly what I mentioned. Smaller images may have some page sub-allocation strategy. Small buffers in Metal are sub-allocated from a larger 128K buffer, but that's harder with texture data. Not that on macOS Intel, the page size is higher so the need to atlas is even more true there. 256x256, mips 8, Astc: 21872, Metal: 32768 <- mips add up to 16K x 4/3 approx = 21845, but due to align and 16K page size, padded out to 32K 256x256, mips 1, Astc: 16384, Metal: 16384 <- this is the exact fit 32x32x16B = 16K

Try using -MO instead of -frecord-sources. That's the only way things worked on Mac, even though this flag is deprecated.

It's not really padding, it's page alignment. On console, you could sometimes pack buffer data into the unused bytes. Android has similar hardware and alignment requirements. Sometimes mips have to be aligned to the page size, but maybe Metal team can relay more here. It's gpu specific, so I doubt they'll want to commit to details. Also hardware often has a packed mip tail in order to cut page use for smaller mip sizes. Is your output showing the buffers that you generated to upload to Vulkan textures. These are linear block order texture data, and not the tiled order blocks used by the hw that may be aligned to texture pages. Some systems also have to pad mips out to a power-of-two size. On desktop the tile size is 64KB. On iOS the tile size is 16KB. Here are tileSizes. Format Desktop(64K) Mobile (16K) ASTC/BC7 256x256 128x128 BC1/ETCr11 512x256 256x128

This problem has been happening for years now. It happens on Intel and M1, so it's not tied to hardware. There's something wrong with the forum software that generates the http response. Seems like this is a client-side type error. Clearing all cookies on the browser was recommended online, and seems to have corrected the issue for now.

Seems like this is a client-side type error. Clearing all cookies on the browser was recommended online, and seems to have corrected the issue for now.

That sounds even more of a stall if one is trying to use double-buffering. All Apple examples always fallback to triple-buffer to buy more time, and so I'd encourage fixing this api. Vulkan doesn't stall in vkImageAquire for long at all, less that 3ms. Metal can take 30-40ms when the gpu is saturated. In Vulkan, that allows a single command buffer to hold the backbuffer aquire and present to the backbuffer.

This is also why you need to atlas, use array textures, etc. Then each of those can fill up multiple texture pages. Megatexture is just an extreme case of atlasing, where the uv and pages are dynamically adjusted to parts of a single texture.

There's a minimum page size (typically 32k to 64K) to all GPUs. So you can't really defeat that. That affects partially-resident textures, where you load chunks of mips. Also I wouldn't use anything above ASTC6x6 personally. Fitting 64 or 144 samples to two colors and some gradients is a way to turn textures to garbage.

I finally got this to work by designating the Storyboard as a NSView (Instead of NSImageView), and then adding the NSImageView with addSubview of that. But now I need the subview to auto-layout to the parent's bounds. That's at least a fixable problem.

The proposed solution of explicitly setting x86_64 arm64 on macOS targets doesn't work for me either with Xcode 13.1. My .a library files, and frameworks all report that they are missing the arm64 architecture when trying to build for "Any Mac". This is because the scheme is "Debug" and that activates active arch only (in my case x86_64). The debug setting of "build for active arch only" is not being overridden by the setting to build a universal app when "Any Mac" is set. Setting the "Build" target to "Release" avoids all the crazy errors when set to "Any Mac". But then there's a crazy error from my use of modules. mm_malloc.h must not have an equivalent on macOS arm64, or the module isn't built properly for the arm64 build. This was originally from sse intrinsics, so I'll look to replace that with something uninverals. #include <mm_malloc.h> Module '_Builtin_intrinsics.intel.mm_malloc' requires feature 'x86'

Also isn't CADisplayLink supposed to synchronize the frames. And we have a semaphore that counts down from the drawable count when before we request nextDrawable which also seems redundant. The problem is that the program thread wants to get onto the next frame, but can't due to the requirement to call nextDrawable. Even Apple's docs state this should be called as late in the frame as possible, but when that call takes 24ms, it feels like it's doing the job of the display link.

This supplied best practices example isn't performant. It incurs all the stalls using a single command buffer. https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/3DDrawing/Conceptual/MTLBestPracticesGuide/Drawables.html Here's a more realistic example of what happens using a single command buffer. beginCommandBuffer beginEncoding 98% of commands to offscreen endEncoding <- this is where I currently end/commit the 98% command buffer to start driver processing 20ms+ stall on nextDrawable under heavy gpu load beginEncoding 2% of commands to drawable (say a blit from offscreen to drawable) endEncoding 1ms+ stall on presentDrawable (some stall then drawable.present added to addScheduledHandler) endCommandBuffer [cb commit] <- this is where commands are sent to queue and the driver Ideally the nextDrawable and presentDrawable should be off in their own little core using thread, so the main thread on a big core isn't stalled out. The case we have are 90 alpha blended quads on iOS that cause an 11ms gpu time + the rest of rendering. This then stalls the nextDrawable returning drawables to the pool, and with a single command buffer stalls processing the next frame and getting to the next cpu update. There is also still no test for isDrawableAvailable in the pool.

Those functions don't deal with the small allocation sub-allocation strategy used with 128K buffers. So gpu capture tends to just report 128K for the sizes regardless of whether each buffer is shared inside the same 128K buffer. The tool needed to dedupe those allocations. I filed a forum post and feedback assistant on this, and Apple was looking to fix the issue.

This is happening even with Monterey macOS 12.0.1 on a 16" MBP. So this is a wide-ranging problem. Only Safari works for reading forum messages.

I'm trying to read gltf files which consist of json, a bin file, and a series of png images all in the same folder. How do I ship a viewer for this, if the viewer must be sandboxed, but the sandboxed app can only read the .gltf file that was supplied. The "Related Items" seems to imply the same name with different extensions, but here the image names can be anything. Apple's ommision of gltf reader support in ModelIO requires me to supply my own reader, and I can't ask users to run usdzconvert first. But usdz has a similar file structure with separate images. All for sandboxing, except when it doesn't work. Also trying to submit this question in Chrome results in "Bad Message 431 reason: Request Header Fields Too Large". so then I had to switch to Safari. Basically do users need to pick the folder containing the gltf, instead of the gltf file itself. Then the sandbox grants access to that folder and I can read-only any contents therein. This is rather unintuitive from the open panel to pick that. I've shipped poplular tools that had to be pulled from the App Store due to sandboxing.