Yes started in 18.4 AFAIK (not reproducible on 18.3.2)

(but I do want to note that thank you for continued tries at fixing FamilyActivityPicker 🙏)

actually maybe its not related to "SFSafariViewController" and rather any full-screen View Controller presented on top causes this bug

@Engineer Ok apologies for the delay and thank you for listening to the feedback! ❤️ The feedback is: FB17108036

Hi there, thank you for the response. At the moment, I am not 100% clear on what's going on so don't want to go through the process of filing Feedback. My "updated" understanding is that the alarm maybe does go off, but there's some special behavior if the phone is not locked (ex. its in "foreground") or app is in foreground while the alarm goes off. If I lock my phone, even with 1 minute differential I see the alarm go off. If I don't lock my phone, what maybe happens (at least I sometimes see it in debugger) is that the app runs to receive the "alerting" update (even if its technically in background?), but there's no UI anywhere showing that the alert is going off. Sometimes I do hear the sound (there's sound of alarm going off with no UI anywhere). I utilized open source sample code around AlarmKit and for that I do see the UI appear, where maybe it does because they implemented the custom widget? (but even their UI still shows inconsistencies depending on state of device/app) Of course I could be confused (surely am somewhat!), but my wish is that it would just always show UI (Lock Screen or "notification") / play sound, no matter what state there is.

for the same code (didn't change anything - just keep toggling same app code 1 minute apart): If I set alarm 1 minute later and lock the phone -> I see alarm go off and UI shows in Lock Screen with the alarm sound If I set alarm 1 minute later and do NOT lock the screen (looking at Home Screen while I wait) -> I get nothing (likely my app code is executing something though) without fail it does that behavior atm

+1? does reverting to the deprecated API's helped?

Great post! Amazing detail. @parkjju If I understand what you are saying correctly, you are essentially saying that CLMonitor region monitoring in the background is not reliable? If so, I am also finding the same in iOS 26 at least. Sometimes it wakes up the app. Sometimes it does not. Similar notes here: https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/768373?answerId=830944022&page=1#866073022

Also to add another data point on top: I switched my code (iOS 26) from CLMonitor to legacy CLCircularRegion and everything started working perfectly. Haven't had one issue. On the other hand, with CLMonitor I was questioning everything. I was doing deep research on what are the "hidden rules" on how quickly the enter/exit would fire, etc. CLCircularRegion just worked. (just in case: FB21142241)

same thing except for me it started happening with 18.4 or 18.5: FB17322530 iOS 26.1 seems to maybe have fixed it but there might be a new issue in iOS 26.2 RC (much worse?): https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/809410

Some other details: this looks to happen right when I open my device for the first time (after not using my phone for like 6+ hours)...theoretically there could be a chance that because "iOS is just waking up" (not 100% the case since the phone is on and charging) there's some odd bug where things go wrong using iOS 26.2 before RC seemed to be OK My hope is that this is just some odd side-effect due to my device state, but if it's not, it's critical for all Screen Time apps to test this & report.

got it again: today it was all the limits once more few days ago it was just some of the limits the behavior is the same: first device pick up of the day (didn't even open the app), and immediately limits get activated I'm not sure if this is any different than the bug here: https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/793747 BUT I only started getting THIS specific behavior in 26.2 RC...so maybe it is new?

Just got a user email from iOS 26.2 that looks like this bug (Again, I'm not sure if this is any different than the bug here but sounds different due to the explicit start on iOS 26.2 and that its strictly a beginning-of-the-day-thing: https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/793747)

[quote='870753022, SaulD18, /thread/809410?answerId=870753022#870753022, /profile/SaulD18'] Found a possible reproduction pattern correlated with plugging the device into power [/quote] I think you may be onto something with this as I maybe am also reproducing it easier if I pick-up my phone while it's plugged in. Still happening on iOS 26.3 beta. Thank you everyone for participating :) Regardless of these new issues, I've felt like the Screen Time framework has been getting more stable since iOS 16 so I do want to thank the Apple engineers for that.

see also: https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/809410