When: Embedding a Image with a symbol effect in a stack view in SwiftUI, and putting this in a List Actual: The symbols animate when scrolling that item in and out of the view Expected: The symbol doesn't animate until the value changes. I have the following code which is boiled down from my actual code where the animating value is a @Model object property (other animations work fine when their animation's value is watching the same property.) I've boiled it down to the below examples: The top example works as expected (no symbol animations on scroll) The bottom example animates the symbols every time they scroll in to view #Preview { VStack { List { ForEach(1...100, id: \.self) { index in Image(systemName: "square.3.layers.3d") .symbolEffect(.bounce, value: index) } } List { ForEach(1...100, id: \.self) { index in HStack { Image(systemName: "square.3.layers.3d") .symbolEffect(.bounce, value: index) } } } } } This happens on Mac and iOS. I'm running Xcode 15.3 RC2 but it also happens in Xcode 15.2 I've found this will happen whether embedding in a HStack, VStack or ZStack but seems fine in a Group. I've tried adding a id() modifier to the HStack to give it an explicit identifier but this doesn't seem to work. Is there something I'm missing here?