Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

Why does SwiftUI Text(date, style: .relative) show the same duration for different dates?
I’m using SwiftUI’s Text(_:style:) with the .relative style to show how long ago a date occurred. According to the docs: A style displaying a date as relative to now. I expected it to show the precise difference between a past date and the current date. However, I noticed that two dates that are 3 days apart both display the same relative string under certain conditions. Code snippet to reproduce- (using GMT time zone and the system calendar) IMPORTANT: To reproduce this, set your Mac’s system clock to 8 September 2025, 3:00 AM. SwiftUI’s relative style uses the current system time as its reference point, so changing the clock is necessary to see the behavior. Settings Mac is set to Central European Time zone (but this behaviour was also reproduced by one of my app's users in the US.) Mac OS Sequoia 15.5 XCode 16.4 tested on an iOS Simulator and a real iPhone both running iOS 18.5 struct TestDateView: View { var body: some View { // 8. July 10AM to 8. September 3AM = Shows 2 months 2 days let startDate1: Date = Calendar.current.date(from: .init(calendar: .current, timeZone: .gmt, year: 2025, month: 7, day: 8, hour: 10, minute: 0, second: 0))! // 5. July 10AM to 8. September 3AM = Shows 2 months 2 days let startDate2: Date = Calendar.current.date(from: .init(calendar: .current, timeZone: .gmt, year: 2025, month: 7, day: 5, hour: 10, minute: 0, second: 0))! // IMPORTANT!: Need to set MAC's clock to 8. September 3:00 AM to reproduce this bug VStack { Text(startDate1, style: .relative) Text(startDate2, style: .relative) } } } How exactly does the .relative style work internally? Is it expected that different dates can collapse into the same result like this, or is there a better way to use .relative to get more precise results? PS: I know about DateComponents and DateFormatter for exact calculations, but I’d like to understand this approach since it auto-updates natively with no timers or publishers.
0
0
130
Sep ’25
Why does SwiftUI Text(date, style: .relative) show the same duration for different dates?
I’m using SwiftUI’s Text(_:style:) with the .relative style to show how long ago a date occurred. According to the docs: A style displaying a date as relative to now. I expected it to show the precise difference between a past date and the current date. However, I noticed that two dates that are 3 days apart both display the same relative string under certain conditions. Code snippet to reproduce- (using GMT time zone and the system calendar) IMPORTANT: To reproduce this, set your Mac’s system clock to 8 September 2025, 3:00 AM. SwiftUI’s relative style uses the current system time as its reference point, so changing the clock is necessary to see the behavior. Settings Mac is set to Central European Time zone (but this behaviour was also reproduced by one of my app's users in the US.) Mac OS Sequoia 15.5 XCode 16.4 tested on an iOS Simulator and a real iPhone both running iOS 18.5 struct TestDateView: View { var body: some View { // 8. July 10AM to 8. September 3AM = Shows 2 months 2 days let startDate1: Date = Calendar.current.date(from: .init(calendar: .current, timeZone: .gmt, year: 2025, month: 7, day: 8, hour: 10, minute: 0, second: 0))! // 5. July 10AM to 8. September 3AM = Shows 2 months 2 days let startDate2: Date = Calendar.current.date(from: .init(calendar: .current, timeZone: .gmt, year: 2025, month: 7, day: 5, hour: 10, minute: 0, second: 0))! // IMPORTANT!: Need to set MAC's clock to 8. September 3:00 AM to reproduce this bug VStack { Text(startDate1, style: .relative) Text(startDate2, style: .relative) } } } How exactly does the .relative style work internally? Is it expected that different dates can collapse into the same result like this, or is there a better way to use .relative to get more precise results? PS: I know about DateComponents and DateFormatter for exact calculations, but I’d like to understand this approach since it auto-updates natively with no timers or publishers.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
130
Activity
Sep ’25