Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

NetworkExtension URL Filter stops during startup only in TestFlight (NEAgentURLFilterErrorDomain Code=3, NEMembershipCheckerErrorDomain Code=3)
Hi Apple Developer Support / community, I am seeing a URL filter startup failure only in TestFlight builds. The same code path works in development and Ad Hoc builds. App setup: Host app bundle id: com.expleo.protectus.filter.main URL filter control extension bundle id: com.expleo.protectus.filter.main.buf Extension point: com.apple.networkextension.url-filter-control Using NEURLFilterManager / NEURLFilterControlProvider on iOS 26.x App Group and network extension entitlements are configured on host + extension Observed behavior: Extension process starts successfully (pid created) Status changes to starting Then updatePrefilterWithCompletionHandler runs Immediately after, plugin transitions to stopping with error 3 System retries in a loop Key logs: Error Domain=NEAgentURLFilterErrorDomain Code=3 Failed to startFilter NEPIRChecker start block reports: Error Domain=com.apple.CipherML Code=1100 Underlying Error Domain=com.apple.CipherML Code=1800 Message says details are redacted Example sequence: NEURLFilterPlugin ... started with pid ... status changed to starting updatePrefilterWithCompletionHandler enter acceptAgentClients enter setStatus:error ... NEAgentURLFilterErrorDomain Code=3 status changed to stopping with error 3 extension disposed / teardown repeats Important detail: This failure is reproducible in TestFlight only. Same code and configuration works in development and Ad Hoc builds. What we already checked: Extension launches and is discovered correctly by neagent App/extension bundle identifiers are correct App group and network extension entitlements are present in source and archive checks We tested startup gating around local bloom/prefilter readiness We still get NEMembershipCheckerErrorDomain Code=3 with CipherML 1100/1800 in TestFlight Questions: Is NEMembershipCheckerErrorDomain Code=3 in this startup path known to indicate PIR membership/status validation failure in distribution context? Are there TestFlight-specific prerequisites or server-side requirements for PIR/CipherML path that differ from development/Ad Hoc? Is there any supported way to get non-redacted diagnostic details for CipherML 1100/1800 (beyond sysdiagnose submission)? Are there recommended fail-open/fail-closed startup patterns when PIR status is temporarily unavailable? If needed, I can provide: Full sysdiagnose timestamped bundle Exact iOS version and device model Repro steps from clean install Full log stream around NEPIRChecker and NEURLFilterPlugin transitions Thanks in advance.
15
0
1.4k
3w
Using URL Filter + Packet Tunnel Provider for blocked URL statistics and App Store approval
Hi Apple Developer Team, We have an iOS app using Network Extension URL Filtering for content filtering. The filtering works, but we need to maintain statistics such as: Number of blocked/allowed URLs Blocked domains/URLs Browser-specific statistics We don't currently see an API from the URL Filter that reliably provides the blocked URL event/details, we already say the latest introduction of reportEndPoint https://developer.apple.com/documentation/networkextension/neurlfiltermanager/reportendpoint?changes=_3,_3, we do not need it for supervised devices and that is mainly designed for supervised devices. We are considering using NEPacketTunnelProvider alongside the URL Filter to collect network-level statistics while keeping the URL Filter responsible for the actual blocking. Our concern is that Could you please clarify: Is it supported to use URL/Content Filter + NEPacketTunnelProvider together for this purpose? Would using Packet Tunnel to collect statistics/network telemetry be considered a misuse of NEPacketTunnelProvider, since it is primarily intended for VPN functionality? Does adding the packet-tunnel-provider Network Extension entitlement require separate Apple approval? Could this architecture create an App Store review/distribution issue? Is there an Apple-supported API for obtaining the URL/domain and block decision directly from the URL/Content Filter, which would be preferable to monitoring packets? Our goal is not to replace the content filter with Packet Tunnel. We want to keep filtering in the appropriate Network Extension and use the appropriate mechanism to maintain browser-specific blocked/allowed statistics. Thank you.
1
0
224
4w
iOS 26 Message Filter Extension not invoked after conversation is moved to Spam
We're seeing a behavior change with ILMessageFilterExtension on iOS 26 and would like to confirm whether this is expected or a regression. Environment iOS: 26.x Framework: IdentityLookup Extension type: ILMessageFilterExtension Behavior For a new sender: An incoming SMS arrives. handle(_:context:completion:) is invoked. The extension returns a classification. The conversation is moved to the Spam folder. Subsequent SMS messages in the same conversation are delivered to the Spam folder, but handle(_:context:completion:) is no longer invoked for any new messages. Expected behavior We expected the message filter extension to be invoked for every incoming SMS, regardless of the current conversation folder, allowing the extension to evaluate each message independently. Actual behavior Once the conversation is in the Spam folder, all subsequent messages bypass the extension completely. The extension receives no callback, making it impossible to: Re-evaluate new messages using updated filtering logic. Change the classification if sender reputation changes. Apply cloud-based or dynamic filtering policies on subsequent messages. Questions Is this behavior expected in iOS 26? Has the message filtering pipeline changed so that conversations already classified as Spam no longer invoke ILMessageFilterExtension? Is there any documented API or recommended approach to have the extension evaluate every incoming message for an existing Spam conversation? If this is not expected, is this a known issue? If anyone from Apple or other developers can confirm whether this is by design, it would be greatly appreciated.
1
0
457
Aug ’26
NEURLFilterManager.Error 10 after updating to iOS 26.5.2
I'm seeing an issue with NEURLFilterManager on iOS 26.5.2 and wanted to check if anyone else has encountered this. Our URL Filter implementation was working correctly on previous iOS 26.x releases. After updating devices to iOS 26.5.2, the filter no longer starts. The status changes to: Received filter status change: <FilterStatus: 'stopped' errorMessage: 'The operation couldn’t be completed. (NetworkExtension.NEURLFilterManager.Error error 10.)'> What I've verified The same project and implementation worked on earlier iOS versions. The app and extension have the required Network Extension capabilities and entitlements. The extension bundle identifier matches the one configured in NEURLFilterManager. The extension is embedded correctly in the application. I've tried uninstalling/reinstalling the app and rebuilding with the latest Xcode. The issue is reproducible on iOS 26.5.2. The filter never appears to start, and the status immediately changes to stopped with NEURLFilterManager.Error 10. I'm trying to determine: Has anyone else observed this behavior on iOS 26.5.2? Is there any known regression or change in NEURLFilterManager or URL Filter extensions in this release? Does Error 10 indicate a different failure mode on iOS 26.5.2 than on previous releases? If anyone has experienced the same issue or found a workaround, I'd appreciate any guidance. Thanks!
2
0
572
Aug ’26
How to collect statistics for Message Filter Extension and Call Blocking Extension?
Hi everyone, I'm developing an iOS app that includes both a Message Filter Extension and a Call Blocking Extension. I'd like to understand whether there is any supported way to collect or access statistics for these extensions, such as: Number of messages filtered (allowed vs. junk) Number of blocked calls Number of identified calls Extension invocation count Filtering success/failure metrics Any analytics or usage data exposed by the system I understand that these extensions are privacy-sensitive, so I'm not expecting access to user content. I'm specifically looking for aggregate statistics or system-provided metrics that an app can legally and technically access. My questions are: Does iOS expose any APIs or callbacks for collecting usage statistics from a Message Filter Extension? Is there any way to determine how many calls were blocked or identified by a Call Blocking Extension? Are there any recommended Apple-supported approaches for tracking extension usage without violating user privacy? If no APIs are available, is this limitation intentional due to the privacy model of these extensions? I'd appreciate any guidance or best practices from Apple engineers or developers who have worked with these extensions. Thank you!
4
0
894
Jul ’26
Validation for PIR DB canary value
We got a feedback from apple side for our new request PIR server responded, but the canary value is not in the dataset. "www.apple.com/url-filter-test" should be set to 1 So we have validated this using our iOS app pointing to same environment and it is blocking this URL as per expectation as well as we have validated this using below curl docker exec pir-server sh -lc 'grep -n "www.apple.com/url-filter-test" /pir/data/input.txtpb; ls -l /pir/data/input.txtpb /pir/data/url-0.bin /pir/data/url-0.params.txtpb'; curl -sS -i https://ohttp.protectuswebfilter.com/.well-known/private-token-issuer-directory | sed -n '1,40p' Please help us, how they are validating this entry is available or not
2
0
519
Jul ’26
Call Blocking using Call Directory Extension is Broken on iOS 26.5
I just updated my testing device OS to iOS 26.5 and was trying to validate if our sdk is working fine or not and we found Call blocking is not at working for this update. I already seen some of the post regarding call blocking will not work if call to the expected block number is initiated from testing device. So just to clarify that is not the case in our findings.
1
0
718
Jun ’26
Onboarding OHTTP relay
One thing I wanted to confirm, suppose i submit one request to onboard OHTTP relay for one organisation app and it gets approved, so can I re submit the request with different bundle ID for other organisation and same PIR server, same OHTTP server ? Or do we need different domain name ?
1
0
379
May ’26
URL Filter Network Extension
Hello team, I am trying to find out a way to block urls in the chrome browser if it is found in local blocked list cache. I found URL Filter Network very much suitable for my requirement. But I see at multiple places that this solution is only for Enterprise level or MDM or supervised device. So can I run this for normal user ? as my targeting audience would be bank users. One more thing how can I test this in development environment if we need supervised devices and do we need special entitlement ? When trying to run sample project in the simulator then getting below error
15
0
883
Apr ’26
NetworkExtension URL Filter stops during startup only in TestFlight (NEAgentURLFilterErrorDomain Code=3, NEMembershipCheckerErrorDomain Code=3)
Hi Apple Developer Support / community, I am seeing a URL filter startup failure only in TestFlight builds. The same code path works in development and Ad Hoc builds. App setup: Host app bundle id: com.expleo.protectus.filter.main URL filter control extension bundle id: com.expleo.protectus.filter.main.buf Extension point: com.apple.networkextension.url-filter-control Using NEURLFilterManager / NEURLFilterControlProvider on iOS 26.x App Group and network extension entitlements are configured on host + extension Observed behavior: Extension process starts successfully (pid created) Status changes to starting Then updatePrefilterWithCompletionHandler runs Immediately after, plugin transitions to stopping with error 3 System retries in a loop Key logs: Error Domain=NEAgentURLFilterErrorDomain Code=3 Failed to startFilter NEPIRChecker start block reports: Error Domain=com.apple.CipherML Code=1100 Underlying Error Domain=com.apple.CipherML Code=1800 Message says details are redacted Example sequence: NEURLFilterPlugin ... started with pid ... status changed to starting updatePrefilterWithCompletionHandler enter acceptAgentClients enter setStatus:error ... NEAgentURLFilterErrorDomain Code=3 status changed to stopping with error 3 extension disposed / teardown repeats Important detail: This failure is reproducible in TestFlight only. Same code and configuration works in development and Ad Hoc builds. What we already checked: Extension launches and is discovered correctly by neagent App/extension bundle identifiers are correct App group and network extension entitlements are present in source and archive checks We tested startup gating around local bloom/prefilter readiness We still get NEMembershipCheckerErrorDomain Code=3 with CipherML 1100/1800 in TestFlight Questions: Is NEMembershipCheckerErrorDomain Code=3 in this startup path known to indicate PIR membership/status validation failure in distribution context? Are there TestFlight-specific prerequisites or server-side requirements for PIR/CipherML path that differ from development/Ad Hoc? Is there any supported way to get non-redacted diagnostic details for CipherML 1100/1800 (beyond sysdiagnose submission)? Are there recommended fail-open/fail-closed startup patterns when PIR status is temporarily unavailable? If needed, I can provide: Full sysdiagnose timestamped bundle Exact iOS version and device model Repro steps from clean install Full log stream around NEPIRChecker and NEURLFilterPlugin transitions Thanks in advance.
Replies
15
Boosts
0
Views
1.4k
Activity
3w
Using URL Filter + Packet Tunnel Provider for blocked URL statistics and App Store approval
Hi Apple Developer Team, We have an iOS app using Network Extension URL Filtering for content filtering. The filtering works, but we need to maintain statistics such as: Number of blocked/allowed URLs Blocked domains/URLs Browser-specific statistics We don't currently see an API from the URL Filter that reliably provides the blocked URL event/details, we already say the latest introduction of reportEndPoint https://developer.apple.com/documentation/networkextension/neurlfiltermanager/reportendpoint?changes=_3,_3, we do not need it for supervised devices and that is mainly designed for supervised devices. We are considering using NEPacketTunnelProvider alongside the URL Filter to collect network-level statistics while keeping the URL Filter responsible for the actual blocking. Our concern is that Could you please clarify: Is it supported to use URL/Content Filter + NEPacketTunnelProvider together for this purpose? Would using Packet Tunnel to collect statistics/network telemetry be considered a misuse of NEPacketTunnelProvider, since it is primarily intended for VPN functionality? Does adding the packet-tunnel-provider Network Extension entitlement require separate Apple approval? Could this architecture create an App Store review/distribution issue? Is there an Apple-supported API for obtaining the URL/domain and block decision directly from the URL/Content Filter, which would be preferable to monitoring packets? Our goal is not to replace the content filter with Packet Tunnel. We want to keep filtering in the appropriate Network Extension and use the appropriate mechanism to maintain browser-specific blocked/allowed statistics. Thank you.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
224
Activity
4w
iOS 26 Message Filter Extension not invoked after conversation is moved to Spam
We're seeing a behavior change with ILMessageFilterExtension on iOS 26 and would like to confirm whether this is expected or a regression. Environment iOS: 26.x Framework: IdentityLookup Extension type: ILMessageFilterExtension Behavior For a new sender: An incoming SMS arrives. handle(_:context:completion:) is invoked. The extension returns a classification. The conversation is moved to the Spam folder. Subsequent SMS messages in the same conversation are delivered to the Spam folder, but handle(_:context:completion:) is no longer invoked for any new messages. Expected behavior We expected the message filter extension to be invoked for every incoming SMS, regardless of the current conversation folder, allowing the extension to evaluate each message independently. Actual behavior Once the conversation is in the Spam folder, all subsequent messages bypass the extension completely. The extension receives no callback, making it impossible to: Re-evaluate new messages using updated filtering logic. Change the classification if sender reputation changes. Apply cloud-based or dynamic filtering policies on subsequent messages. Questions Is this behavior expected in iOS 26? Has the message filtering pipeline changed so that conversations already classified as Spam no longer invoke ILMessageFilterExtension? Is there any documented API or recommended approach to have the extension evaluate every incoming message for an existing Spam conversation? If this is not expected, is this a known issue? If anyone from Apple or other developers can confirm whether this is by design, it would be greatly appreciated.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
457
Activity
Aug ’26
NEURLFilterManager.Error 10 after updating to iOS 26.5.2
I'm seeing an issue with NEURLFilterManager on iOS 26.5.2 and wanted to check if anyone else has encountered this. Our URL Filter implementation was working correctly on previous iOS 26.x releases. After updating devices to iOS 26.5.2, the filter no longer starts. The status changes to: Received filter status change: <FilterStatus: 'stopped' errorMessage: 'The operation couldn’t be completed. (NetworkExtension.NEURLFilterManager.Error error 10.)'> What I've verified The same project and implementation worked on earlier iOS versions. The app and extension have the required Network Extension capabilities and entitlements. The extension bundle identifier matches the one configured in NEURLFilterManager. The extension is embedded correctly in the application. I've tried uninstalling/reinstalling the app and rebuilding with the latest Xcode. The issue is reproducible on iOS 26.5.2. The filter never appears to start, and the status immediately changes to stopped with NEURLFilterManager.Error 10. I'm trying to determine: Has anyone else observed this behavior on iOS 26.5.2? Is there any known regression or change in NEURLFilterManager or URL Filter extensions in this release? Does Error 10 indicate a different failure mode on iOS 26.5.2 than on previous releases? If anyone has experienced the same issue or found a workaround, I'd appreciate any guidance. Thanks!
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
572
Activity
Aug ’26
How to collect statistics for Message Filter Extension and Call Blocking Extension?
Hi everyone, I'm developing an iOS app that includes both a Message Filter Extension and a Call Blocking Extension. I'd like to understand whether there is any supported way to collect or access statistics for these extensions, such as: Number of messages filtered (allowed vs. junk) Number of blocked calls Number of identified calls Extension invocation count Filtering success/failure metrics Any analytics or usage data exposed by the system I understand that these extensions are privacy-sensitive, so I'm not expecting access to user content. I'm specifically looking for aggregate statistics or system-provided metrics that an app can legally and technically access. My questions are: Does iOS expose any APIs or callbacks for collecting usage statistics from a Message Filter Extension? Is there any way to determine how many calls were blocked or identified by a Call Blocking Extension? Are there any recommended Apple-supported approaches for tracking extension usage without violating user privacy? If no APIs are available, is this limitation intentional due to the privacy model of these extensions? I'd appreciate any guidance or best practices from Apple engineers or developers who have worked with these extensions. Thank you!
Replies
4
Boosts
0
Views
894
Activity
Jul ’26
Validation for PIR DB canary value
We got a feedback from apple side for our new request PIR server responded, but the canary value is not in the dataset. "www.apple.com/url-filter-test" should be set to 1 So we have validated this using our iOS app pointing to same environment and it is blocking this URL as per expectation as well as we have validated this using below curl docker exec pir-server sh -lc 'grep -n "www.apple.com/url-filter-test" /pir/data/input.txtpb; ls -l /pir/data/input.txtpb /pir/data/url-0.bin /pir/data/url-0.params.txtpb'; curl -sS -i https://ohttp.protectuswebfilter.com/.well-known/private-token-issuer-directory | sed -n '1,40p' Please help us, how they are validating this entry is available or not
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
519
Activity
Jul ’26
Requesting Network Extension Capability
One thing I wanted to confirm, suppose i submit one request to onboard OHTTP relay for one organisation app and it gets approved, so can I re submit the request with different bundle ID for other organisation and same PIR server, same OHTTP server ? Or do we need different domain name ?
Replies
18
Boosts
1
Views
1.4k
Activity
Jul ’26
Intercepting the Native Phone Calls
Hello team, I am trying to develop a solution to intercept a native cellular phone call, process its conversation audio or screen call before it is been answered. Do we have any framework to build such kind of feature.
Replies
6
Boosts
0
Views
493
Activity
Jun ’26
Intercepting the native phone calls
Hello team, I am trying to develop a solution to intercept a native cellular phone call, process its conversation audio or screen call before it is been answered. Do we have any framework to build such kind of feature.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
337
Activity
Jun ’26
Call Blocking using Call Directory Extension is Broken on iOS 26.5
I just updated my testing device OS to iOS 26.5 and was trying to validate if our sdk is working fine or not and we found Call blocking is not at working for this update. I already seen some of the post regarding call blocking will not work if call to the expected block number is initiated from testing device. So just to clarify that is not the case in our findings.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
718
Activity
Jun ’26
Requesting URL Filtering capability
Hi Apple team, Could you please let us know the estimated timeline for approval of our OHTTP relay request? We’d appreciate any updates on the current status or next steps from your side. My request number is GZ8425KHD9. Thanks in advance.
Replies
13
Boosts
0
Views
983
Activity
May ’26
Onboarding OHTTP relay
One thing I wanted to confirm, suppose i submit one request to onboard OHTTP relay for one organisation app and it gets approved, so can I re submit the request with different bundle ID for other organisation and same PIR server, same OHTTP server ? Or do we need different domain name ?
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
379
Activity
May ’26
URL Filter Network Extension
Hello team, I am trying to find out a way to block urls in the chrome browser if it is found in local blocked list cache. I found URL Filter Network very much suitable for my requirement. But I see at multiple places that this solution is only for Enterprise level or MDM or supervised device. So can I run this for normal user ? as my targeting audience would be bank users. One more thing how can I test this in development environment if we need supervised devices and do we need special entitlement ? When trying to run sample project in the simulator then getting below error
Replies
15
Boosts
0
Views
883
Activity
Apr ’26
URL Filter OHTTP Gateway
Hello team, We are using below example https://github.com/apple/pir-service-example as a starting point to setup PIR server for our backend, but I am not really understanding what else we need in this example to configure OHTTP gateway. Any help will be appreciated.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
302
Activity
Apr ’26
URL Filter Network Extension
Hello team, I have implemented sample project for URL Filtering as well as setup PIR server at backend but currently I am facing a major issue, If PIR server is re started then the app shows error code 9 every time until. and unless I disconnect and connect it back to internet
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
432
Activity
Apr ’26