I'm currently having the same problem. There are about 180 active paid subscriptions that keep renewing automatically. Since the app has been removed from the store, the subscriptions need to be canceled, but users should still be able to use the app until their subscriptions expire. I’ve removed the app and the subscriptions from the store, but there’s no longer a “Remove from Sale” button. The subscriptions are still renewing automatically, which shouldn’t be happening. What can I do now?