Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

Private Cloud Compute throws guardrailViolation on benign song analysis (FB24938334)
On iOS 27.0, PrivateCloudComputeLanguageModel refuses a large share of harmless requests, and the same requests often succeed when simply re-run. Our app writes a short, general-audience explanation of what a song is about. When the cloud model refuses, the on-device model with .permissiveContentTransformations answers the same prompt without trouble. PCC has no guardrail configuration, so there's nothing on our side to adjust. • Two refusals came within the first sentence of plainly benign text: "Tiny Dancer" (Elton John) at 167 characters, and "In the Ghetto" (Elvis Presley) at 169 characters, while describing snow on a Chicago morning. • Others include "Already Gone" (Eagles), "Do Ya" (ELO) and "We Didn't Start the Fire" (Billy Joel). • It's non-deterministic: "Question" (The Moody Blues) was refused, then succeeded 52 seconds later with an identical request. • Most failures are "Streamed response may contain sensitive or unsafe content", arriving mid-generation, so the rejection seems to target the model's own output rather than the input. • Rewording the instructions to steer the model toward mainstream, general-audience language didn't change the refusal rate. Filed as FB24938334 with 8 logFeedbackAttachment captures (.triggeredGuardrailUnexpectedly), each including the rolled-back rejected draft. Siri language English (US), iPhone 16 Pro. Is PCC's guardrail policy expected to be tuned for content-transformation tasks like this, or is there a recommended pattern for them?
0
0
245
1d
Private Cloud Compute throws guardrailViolation on benign song analysis (FB24938334)
On iOS 27.0, PrivateCloudComputeLanguageModel refuses a large share of harmless requests, and the same requests often succeed when simply re-run. Our app writes a short, general-audience explanation of what a song is about. When the cloud model refuses, the on-device model with .permissiveContentTransformations answers the same prompt without trouble. PCC has no guardrail configuration, so there's nothing on our side to adjust. • Two refusals came within the first sentence of plainly benign text: "Tiny Dancer" (Elton John) at 167 characters, and "In the Ghetto" (Elvis Presley) at 169 characters, while describing snow on a Chicago morning. • Others include "Already Gone" (Eagles), "Do Ya" (ELO) and "We Didn't Start the Fire" (Billy Joel). • It's non-deterministic: "Question" (The Moody Blues) was refused, then succeeded 52 seconds later with an identical request. • Most failures are "Streamed response may contain sensitive or unsafe content", arriving mid-generation, so the rejection seems to target the model's own output rather than the input. • Rewording the instructions to steer the model toward mainstream, general-audience language didn't change the refusal rate. Filed as FB24938334 with 8 logFeedbackAttachment captures (.triggeredGuardrailUnexpectedly), each including the rolled-back rejected draft. Siri language English (US), iPhone 16 Pro. Is PCC's guardrail policy expected to be tuned for content-transformation tasks like this, or is there a recommended pattern for them?
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
245
Activity
1d