Here are the relevant screenshots. App Review history: no active review for version 1.0.10, previous submissions are deleted Subscription page: the subscription itself is now “In Review” Localization on the same subscription page still shows “Waiting for Review” App version page: 1.0.10 is still “Prepare for Submission” That is why I believe the state is inconsistent. The app version is not in review, but the first subscription appears to have partially moved into review anyway.