I've also asked this question (slightly differently) months ago and managed to solve it. See the response to my question here. - https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/124617

I found that changing my picker to use an Enum works: Picker("Pick Something: ", selection: $pickedValue) { 	ForEach(TestState.allCases) { state in 		Text(state.rawValue).tag(state) 	} } Why would this work differently from the initial code? TestState is declared: enum TestState: String, CaseIterable, Identifiable {   case one   case two   var id: String { self.rawValue } }

No, I have not. I found a workaround by wrapping a NSTextField in a NSViewRepresentable but this broke again in Big Sur. So, I am again trying to resolve this. ps. Sorry for only replying now. For some reason I missed the notification.

My app is displaying a default value as the user enters data in the TextField. It is clear that this data that is being displayed will be copied. The problem does not seem to be related to Enabled since it is set in IB. I got it to work by removing the view that had focus (in my case a TextField). When I did this, Copy was enabled and my copy function in code above was called. My problem still seems to be related to providing and telling the system that copy is available when the current first responder cannot handle it. I've tried various things like creating my own NSTextField and trying to override copy but without success. I've also created a new SwiftUI app and posted this thread - https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/667633 since it more clearly shows my issue. ps. Sorry for the late reply. It seems my notifications are not working.

Thanks, that did help. For completeness, I wrote this small sample app that adds a new menu item to the menu and overrides the copy menu. @main struct MenuTestApp: App {   var body: some Scene {     WindowGroup {       ContentView()     }     .commands {       CommandMenu("My Top Menu") {         Button("Sub Menu Item") { print("You pressed sub menu.") }           .keyboardShortcut("S")       }       CommandGroup(replacing: .pasteboard) {         Button("Cut") { print("Cutting something...") }           .keyboardShortcut("X")         Button("Copy") { print("Copying something...") }           .keyboardShortcut("C")         Button("Paste") { print("Pasting something...") }           .keyboardShortcut("V")         Button("Paste and Match Style") { print("Pasting and Matching something...") }           .keyboardShortcut("V", modifiers: [.command, .option, .shift])         Button("Delete") { print("Deleting something...") }           .keyboardShortcut(.delete)         Button("Select All") { print("Selecting something...") }           .keyboardShortcut("A")       }     }   } }

Thanks Eskimo. I would have replied long ago but I did not get notified about your reply :) It is now finally fixed and one can now click on the alarm bell at the top of the post to get notified again. Yea!

I've raised a TSI for this and the conclusion was that this is not possible. My work-around was to add a specific menu item with its own shortcut. It is not as elegant as I would have liked, but it works.

I've raised a TSI for this and the conclusion was that it is not possible. NSTextView and NSTextField would have to be changed to allow this. The issue is that they do not pass the copy: selector up the responder chain when it is not handled so it stops there.

@satcol, could you please share the exact details of how you linked the XcodeKit lib? I've added XcodeKit as a linked binary under Build Phases but when I link, it gives a linker error: "framework not found XcodeKit".

I can answer my own question about embedding and signing XcodeKit. I had my project selected instead of the target extension. Steps to link XcodeKit (just in case someone else needs exact steps): Select your top-level project in the Project Navigator. Under TARGETS, select your extension to see its settings. In the General tab, scroll down to Frameworks and Libraries. For a new extension, it will show two libs: 1) Cocoa.framework; 2) XcodeKit.framework. Both have the option Do Not Embed selected. Change XcodeKit.framework to Embed & Sign. Rebuild. I can also confirm this resolved the issue.

The strangest thing now happened. The extensions that worked a day ago no longer work. They are not even there when I open System Preferences Extensions. It is as if it never existed. There was no reboot through the night, my macBook was closed. How can this be? Nothing that I tried (even reboot) is helping. I can even create a new project and follow the steps to create an extension but not even debugging works (it starts debugging but the extension is not under the Editor menu in xcode. Any suggestions?

OK, I knew I was missing something stupid: I should not be using iPhone 13 Pro for the video, but an iPhone 13 Pro Max. That gives the correct resolution. Bonus tip: Make use of iMovie's built-in support for generating app previews (yes, I know this should be obvious, but just in case). This did allow me to record my video on my iPhone 13 Pro and still save it in the correct resolution.

Thanks. I am not sure what to do with this tread since the problem was not a code problem but a port being reserved by XQuartz. Thanks for the advice on netstat. I will use it in the future but it seems it would not have picked up the problem either since the port was not open, it was just being reserved. I cannot confirm since I've uninstalled XQuartz to resolve my issue (did not have the option to move other port). I am marking this as the answer purely to close the thread, and in case anyone ever gets to it. Let me know if you disagree.

I found something that fixed my problem but I'm not sure it is the right way of doing things. Setting the horizontal content compression resistance priority to defaultLow made it scroll correctly. The makeUIView function below shows the full solution. func makeUIView(context: Context) -> UIViewType { // Setup text view: // ---------------- let textView = UITextField() textView.delegate = context.coordinator textView.setContentCompressionResistancePriority(.defaultLow, for: .horizontal) // Creae a dummy view for the inputView (keyboard) so that the default // keyboard is not shown: let dummyView = UIView(frame: CGRect.zero) textView.inputView = dummyView return textView }

I cannot change the code because It is in a 3rd party library for which I do not have the code. The other alternative would be to write a wrapper for the 3rd party class but that felt less elegant that the custom Binding. Seeing that the Binding works, I was wondering what it was missing and why it is not working. Is @Published adding some other functionality that could be simulated somehow.