Resubmission stuck "Waiting for Review" 96+ hours - prior TestFlight approval on same 4.3(b) grounds - App ID 6759586097

Hello,

I'm hoping someone from the App Review team can look into this situation, which has specific context that I believe makes it worth a careful look. Thank you in advance for your time.

I'm hoping someone from the App Review team can look into this situation, which I believe has specific context that makes it worth a careful look.

My app YADA: You've Already Met (App ID: 6759586097) has been in "Waiting for Review" since Wednesday May 6 at 7:44 PM ET - now over 96 hours. I have an open support case (20000112508151) filed Friday with no response yet.

I'm not writing simply to flag the wait - I want to explain why this submission deserves a thoughtful second look on the merits.

When YADA was submitted for TestFlight beta review, it was flagged under Guideline 4.3(b) for the same reason as the App Store rejection. I appealed, explained the differentiating mechanic, and an Apple reviewer evaluated the argument and approved the app for external testing. That approval is on record. I'm asking for consistency with that prior decision.

YADA's core mechanic is genuinely unlike any dating app currently on the App Store. A user privately adds someone they already know to a list. That person receives no information about who added them. A match is only revealed when both people have independently and privately added each other. If the feeling isn't mutual, nothing is ever disclosed. There is no browsing of strangers, no algorithmic recommendations, no swiping, and no rejection possible because neither party knows they've been added until both have added each other simultaneously.

Critically, YADA does not ask users to declare their gender or sexual preferences - because the mechanic doesn't require it.

This makes YADA the only interest-discovery platform on the App Store that works entirely without those declarations, which creates a uniquely safe experience for LGBTQ+ users and young people who are not ready to publicly disclose their orientation. No equivalent experience exists on the App Store.

The App Store rejection also included 5.1.1 and 2.1 issues, both of which I fully resolved - redesigning the contacts permission flow with a proper in-app explanation screen and directly answering Apple's question about data handling - with a new build submitted alongside my Resolution Center reply.

I'm not asking for special treatment. I'm asking for the opportunity to have the full argument evaluated by a reviewer with the time to consider it, consistent with how the TestFlight review was handled.

Support case: 20000112508151. App ID: 6759586097. Submission ID: abdf8b5b-5ea0-46a4-8a0b-fb58320fa701.

Thank You

Answered by App Review in 887468022

Thank you for your post. We're investigating and will contact you in App Store Connect to provide further assistance. If you continue to experience issues during review, please contact us.

Accepted Answer

Thank you for your post. We're investigating and will contact you in App Store Connect to provide further assistance. If you continue to experience issues during review, please contact us.

Issue resolved - requesting moderator removal of this thread as the content is no longer relevant.

Hi, following up on this thread with a new development that I hope the App Review team can assist with.

Since this post, significant progress was made. The App Review Board reviewed my 4.3(b) appeal and determined the original rejection was not valid - YADA is no longer considered in violation of Guideline 4.3. That was a meaningful outcome and I am grateful for it.

However, a separate Guideline 1.2 issue was identified during the Board review. I implemented all required precautions immediately - block, report, and EULA - submitted a screen recording demonstrating all three per Ingrid's instructions, and resubmitted build 85 the same day on May 27, 2026.

Build 85 has now been in Waiting for Review for 7 days. I have filed an expedited review request, both confirmed. I have an active support case (102905235397). I replied to the App Review Board thread directly. I have done everything asked of me immediately and thoroughly.

I am one review decision away from approval on an app I have spent almost a decade building. Any assistance getting build 85 moving would mean everything.

App ID: 6759586097. Build 85. Support case: 102905235397.

Thank you.

Following up again - build 86 was submitted on June 5 addressing both issues from the build 85 rejection (5.1.1(iv) and 5.1.2). Now 5 days in Waiting for Review with an expedited request filed. App ID: 6759586097, support case: 102905235397. Any assistance appreciated.

Resubmission stuck "Waiting for Review" 96+ hours - prior TestFlight approval on same 4.3(b) grounds - App ID 6759586097
 
 
Q