Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Created

Support for trailing accessory views in Tab (sidebarAdaptable TabView)
In iOS 18, TabView with .tabViewStyle(.sidebarAdaptable) introduced a powerful adaptive pattern — tabs in compact, sidebar in regular. However, the current Tab API only supports a title and an image (icon). There is no way to provide a trailing accessory view (e.g., a secondary icon or indicator) for sidebar rows. This is a meaningful gap in the API, because trailing accessories are a well-established pattern throughout UIKit and SwiftUI. Precedent in Apple's own design language Apple already supports trailing accessories in many analogous contexts: UITableViewCell / UICollectionViewListCell — support accessories (disclosure indicators, checkmarks, custom views) via UICellAccessory. UIListContentConfiguration — allows leading and trailing content in list rows. SwiftUI List rows — support Label, HStack with trailing elements, .badge(), and swipeActions. NavigationLink — automatically renders a disclosure chevron as a trailing accessory. UITabSidebarItem (UIKit, iOS 18) — supports configurationUpdateHandler and cell accessories at the UIKit level. The sidebar of a .sidebarAdaptable TabView is visually identical to a List — yet its rows lack the accessory support that List rows have had for years. Real-world example: Photos app Apple's own Photos app (iPadOS 18+) demonstrates this exact need. In its sidebar, the "Recently Deleted" row displays a trailing lock icon to indicate that authentication is required to view the album. This is a meaningful UX element — it communicates state at a glance, without requiring the user to tap into the item. Third-party developers building with TabView(.sidebarAdaptable) have no public API to replicate this pattern. The Tab view builder's label closure is decomposed into a discrete title and image; any additional views (including Spacer() and trailing Image views within an HStack) are silently discarded by the system. What we've tried Custom label closure with HStack — trailing views are ignored. The system extracts only the first Image and Text. .badge() modifier — only supports Int or Text, not custom views such as icons. Label with complex content — the system normalizes it to icon + title. The only viable path today is to bridge to UIKit's UITabBarController and customize UITabSidebarItem directly, which defeats the purpose of using SwiftUI's declarative TabView API. Proposed API A trailing accessory modifier on Tab, consistent with existing SwiftUI patterns: Tab("Recently Deleted", systemImage: "trash", value: "deleted") { RecentlyDeletedView() } .tabSidebarAccessory { Image(systemName: "lock.fill") .foregroundStyle(.secondary) } // Option B: Text accessory (e.g., counts, status labels) Tab("Inbox", systemImage: "tray", value: "inbox") { InboxView() } .tabSidebarAccessory { Text("12") .font(.subheadline) .foregroundStyle(.secondary) } // Option C: Combined text + image accessory Tab("Shared Albums", systemImage: "rectangle.stack", value: "shared") { SharedAlbumsView() } .tabSidebarAccessory { HStack(spacing: 4) { Text("3 new") .font(.caption) .foregroundStyle(.secondary) Image(systemName: "person.2.fill") .foregroundStyle(.blue) } } Environment Platform: iPadOS / macOS Catalyst iOS version: 18.0+ Xcode: 16.0+ Component: SwiftUI TabView with .tabViewStyle(.sidebarAdaptable) Summary The Tab API should support trailing accessory content for sidebar rows, bringing it in line with the accessory support already available in UITableViewCell, UICollectionViewListCell, UIListContentConfiguration, and SwiftUI List. Apple's own Photos app demonstrates the need for this capability, yet no public API exists for third-party developers to achieve it.
2
0
128
Feb ’26
UITabGroup child tabs ignoring viewControllerProvider in Sidebar
Hi, I am implementing a sidebar navigation using UITabBarController with the new UITabGroup API on and above iPadOS 18. I’ve encountered an issue where selecting a child UITab within a group does not seem to trigger the child's own viewControllerProvider. Instead, the UITabBarController displays the ViewController associated with the parent UITabGroup. The Issue: In the snippet below, when I tap "Item 2A" or "Item 2B" in the iPad sidebar, the app displays the emptyVC (clear background) defined in the section2Group provider, rather than the teal or cyan ViewControllers defined in the individual child tabs. let item2A = UITab( title: "Item 2A", image: UIImage(systemName: "a.circle"), identifier: "tab.section2.item2a" ) { _ in self.createViewController( title: "Section 2 - Item 2A", color: .systemTeal, description: "Part of Section 2A group" ) } let item2B = UITab( title: "Item 2B", image: UIImage(systemName: "b.circle"), identifier: "tab.section2.item2b" ) { _ in self.createViewController( title: "Section 2 - Item 2B", color: .systemCyan, description: "Part of Section 2B group" ) } item2A.preferredPlacement = .sidebarOnly item2B.preferredPlacement = .sidebarOnly let section2Group = UITabGroup( title: "Section 2", image: UIImage(systemName: "folder.fill"), identifier: "tabgroup.section2", children: [item2A, item2B] ) { _ in // This provider seems to take precedence over children let emptyVC = UIViewController() emptyVC.view.backgroundColor = .clear return emptyVC } section2Group.preferredPlacement = .sidebarOnly tabs.append(section2Group) The Crash: If I attempt to resolve this by removing the viewControllerProvider from the UITabGroup (with the intent that only children should provide views), the application crashes at runtime. The exception indicates that all tabs within the sidebar must have an associated ViewController, suggesting that the UITabGroup requires a provider even if it is intended to act purely as a visual container. Kindly clarify the following: Is it the intended behavior for UITabGroup to override the viewControllerProvider of its children during sidebar selection? Why does the API require the UITabGroup to return a ViewController if the selection target is a child UITab? Is there a specific configuration or delegate method required to allow the UITabBarController to "pass through" the selection to the child tab's provider? I would appreciate any guidance on whether this is an API limitation or if there is a different structural approach recommended for grouped sidebar items.
1
0
114
Jan ’26
Support for trailing accessory views in Tab (sidebarAdaptable TabView)
In iOS 18, TabView with .tabViewStyle(.sidebarAdaptable) introduced a powerful adaptive pattern — tabs in compact, sidebar in regular. However, the current Tab API only supports a title and an image (icon). There is no way to provide a trailing accessory view (e.g., a secondary icon or indicator) for sidebar rows. This is a meaningful gap in the API, because trailing accessories are a well-established pattern throughout UIKit and SwiftUI. Precedent in Apple's own design language Apple already supports trailing accessories in many analogous contexts: UITableViewCell / UICollectionViewListCell — support accessories (disclosure indicators, checkmarks, custom views) via UICellAccessory. UIListContentConfiguration — allows leading and trailing content in list rows. SwiftUI List rows — support Label, HStack with trailing elements, .badge(), and swipeActions. NavigationLink — automatically renders a disclosure chevron as a trailing accessory. UITabSidebarItem (UIKit, iOS 18) — supports configurationUpdateHandler and cell accessories at the UIKit level. The sidebar of a .sidebarAdaptable TabView is visually identical to a List — yet its rows lack the accessory support that List rows have had for years. Real-world example: Photos app Apple's own Photos app (iPadOS 18+) demonstrates this exact need. In its sidebar, the "Recently Deleted" row displays a trailing lock icon to indicate that authentication is required to view the album. This is a meaningful UX element — it communicates state at a glance, without requiring the user to tap into the item. Third-party developers building with TabView(.sidebarAdaptable) have no public API to replicate this pattern. The Tab view builder's label closure is decomposed into a discrete title and image; any additional views (including Spacer() and trailing Image views within an HStack) are silently discarded by the system. What we've tried Custom label closure with HStack — trailing views are ignored. The system extracts only the first Image and Text. .badge() modifier — only supports Int or Text, not custom views such as icons. Label with complex content — the system normalizes it to icon + title. The only viable path today is to bridge to UIKit's UITabBarController and customize UITabSidebarItem directly, which defeats the purpose of using SwiftUI's declarative TabView API. Proposed API A trailing accessory modifier on Tab, consistent with existing SwiftUI patterns: Tab("Recently Deleted", systemImage: "trash", value: "deleted") { RecentlyDeletedView() } .tabSidebarAccessory { Image(systemName: "lock.fill") .foregroundStyle(.secondary) } // Option B: Text accessory (e.g., counts, status labels) Tab("Inbox", systemImage: "tray", value: "inbox") { InboxView() } .tabSidebarAccessory { Text("12") .font(.subheadline) .foregroundStyle(.secondary) } // Option C: Combined text + image accessory Tab("Shared Albums", systemImage: "rectangle.stack", value: "shared") { SharedAlbumsView() } .tabSidebarAccessory { HStack(spacing: 4) { Text("3 new") .font(.caption) .foregroundStyle(.secondary) Image(systemName: "person.2.fill") .foregroundStyle(.blue) } } Environment Platform: iPadOS / macOS Catalyst iOS version: 18.0+ Xcode: 16.0+ Component: SwiftUI TabView with .tabViewStyle(.sidebarAdaptable) Summary The Tab API should support trailing accessory content for sidebar rows, bringing it in line with the accessory support already available in UITableViewCell, UICollectionViewListCell, UIListContentConfiguration, and SwiftUI List. Apple's own Photos app demonstrates the need for this capability, yet no public API exists for third-party developers to achieve it.
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
128
Activity
Feb ’26
UITabGroup child tabs ignoring viewControllerProvider in Sidebar
Hi, I am implementing a sidebar navigation using UITabBarController with the new UITabGroup API on and above iPadOS 18. I’ve encountered an issue where selecting a child UITab within a group does not seem to trigger the child's own viewControllerProvider. Instead, the UITabBarController displays the ViewController associated with the parent UITabGroup. The Issue: In the snippet below, when I tap "Item 2A" or "Item 2B" in the iPad sidebar, the app displays the emptyVC (clear background) defined in the section2Group provider, rather than the teal or cyan ViewControllers defined in the individual child tabs. let item2A = UITab( title: "Item 2A", image: UIImage(systemName: "a.circle"), identifier: "tab.section2.item2a" ) { _ in self.createViewController( title: "Section 2 - Item 2A", color: .systemTeal, description: "Part of Section 2A group" ) } let item2B = UITab( title: "Item 2B", image: UIImage(systemName: "b.circle"), identifier: "tab.section2.item2b" ) { _ in self.createViewController( title: "Section 2 - Item 2B", color: .systemCyan, description: "Part of Section 2B group" ) } item2A.preferredPlacement = .sidebarOnly item2B.preferredPlacement = .sidebarOnly let section2Group = UITabGroup( title: "Section 2", image: UIImage(systemName: "folder.fill"), identifier: "tabgroup.section2", children: [item2A, item2B] ) { _ in // This provider seems to take precedence over children let emptyVC = UIViewController() emptyVC.view.backgroundColor = .clear return emptyVC } section2Group.preferredPlacement = .sidebarOnly tabs.append(section2Group) The Crash: If I attempt to resolve this by removing the viewControllerProvider from the UITabGroup (with the intent that only children should provide views), the application crashes at runtime. The exception indicates that all tabs within the sidebar must have an associated ViewController, suggesting that the UITabGroup requires a provider even if it is intended to act purely as a visual container. Kindly clarify the following: Is it the intended behavior for UITabGroup to override the viewControllerProvider of its children during sidebar selection? Why does the API require the UITabGroup to return a ViewController if the selection target is a child UITab? Is there a specific configuration or delegate method required to allow the UITabBarController to "pass through" the selection to the child tab's provider? I would appreciate any guidance on whether this is an API limitation or if there is a different structural approach recommended for grouped sidebar items.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
114
Activity
Jan ’26