I figured out what the problem was.....ME :( I incorrectly thought that the announcements around this new pricing affected subscription based pricing, but that does not appear to be the case. It's been awhile since we set up (subscription) pricing so when I went to look at the pricing, I went to General/Pricing and Availability instead of Features/Subscriptions. I had been thinking all along that something was a bit off as there was only 1 price listed and there should have been 2, one for each of our SUBSCRIPTIONS.